24 responses

  1. Mr. Adutwum Asare
    March 17, 2010

    i want to know more about illness and diseases

    Reply

  2. samina
    September 29, 2010

    I like this article because in this article the writer work so beautifuuly and teach the persons so nicely and huredly

    Reply

  3. sisi
    November 15, 2010

    slt cv waktah thal ani sisi bayyyyyyyyyyyyyy

    Reply

  4. Sona Paris
    April 5, 2011

    Thank You so much for the information! You managed to present this article in a way, that be you a doctor, or a musician, or a linguist like me, you can’t help admiring it even though the theme is so sad. Successful work You have done! My Congratulations!

    Reply

  5. giu
    December 2, 2011

    the information is really good

    Reply

  6. Maria Salamanca
    June 25, 2012

    The information is really good
    Thanks

    Reply

  7. Alesis
    March 13, 2013

    Interesting article, but a bit simplistic. The words “disease” and “illness” can legitimately be used interchangeably, for instance, in the case of mental illnesses, since all mental illnesses are brain diseases. The presence of pathogens is not necessary for disease to occur, and knowing the cause of disease is not necessary to identify it as a disease. In the case of disease, dysfunction is observed (phenomenology), then one looks for the underlying mechanism for that dysfunction (pathophysiology), and from there one attempts to identify the cause (etiology). But, many diseases have unknown causes, and many have only partly understood mechanisms. So, while some use the words “disease” and “illness” in very specific ways, not all do. Be mindful of this, because not all biomedical researchers carry the same assumption as the author of this article.

    Reply

    • Rob
      December 13, 2013

      Alesis states “all mental illnesses are brain diseases”. Can I just point out, in case anyone reads this and thinks that Alesis has some evidence for this, MENTAL ILLNESS IS NOT A DISEASE. There is no clear evidence for biological causes for mental illness, most modern research (that isn’t funded by drug companies) is indicating psycho-social causes, such as trauma.

      While we’re at it: addiction isn’t a disease either.

      Good article by the way!

      Reply

      • Barry Benedict
        September 8, 2016

        I wish people would stop making a simple explanation difficult.
        All a person has to do in this instance is call it a disease when there is an outside pathogen entering the body and an illness when there is NO outside pathogen.
        Mental ”illness” would thus not be a disease and the common cold would be.
        Why do they feel it demeaning to call alcoholism an illness and not a disease? That’s the only reason I can find for so calling it.
        We are so concerned with not hurting someone’s feelings we go out of our way to confuse the issue.
        What possible difference would it make if we used concrete pathogens for disease and everything else (such as mental problems) illnesses?
        It certainly wouldn’t make calling cancer an illness and not a disease a problem because in this case, the pathogen would be the malformed cells which are invading the body therefor a disease.
        It couldn’t be any more misleading than it now is.

        Reply

      • Hamdee
        September 30, 2016

        PLS TELL ME MORE ABOUT DISEASES, SICKNESS AND ILLNESS

        Reply

    • Steph
      January 17, 2018

      Alesis –

      If mental illnesses were brain diseases – of known, or unknown, aetiology- they would be pathologies of the central nervous system, and not illnesses of the mind. As such, they should be treated by neurologists, not psychiatrists, and all of psychiatry should be absorbed or absorbable by neurology.

      Not only does this show no indication of occurring, but it cannot occur. Psychiatrists do things that no neurologist does or can legally do -namely, to take and treat as a patient someone who wants nothing to do with him.

      The role of coercion in psychiatry, and how it sets psychiatry a part from medicine, is a topic that has been widely ignored.

      If this all interests you, I can recommend no one’s works more highly than that of Dr Thomas Szasz.

      All three dozen of his books are excellent; perhaps “Psychiatry the Science of Lies” would be an engaging and even fun first read and introduction to his observations and thoughts.

      Reply

  8. Mohd.Tarique.qamar.
    January 27, 2015

    its clear within me thats its a very easyly to solved our problems and infact cover your time propepr to use this site and can be a good knowlegious think.I think all persion accepted this choice for best result.Thanks

    Reply

  9. Steph
    December 6, 2016

    Thomas Szasz brilliantly contrasted “illness” and “disease” in his penetrating explanation of why so-called mental illnesses are not literal diseases.

    He also lays bare what a psychiatrist judges when diagnosing a patient as mentally ill as opposed to mentally diseased.

    Szasz’s books are as thoroughly enjoyable as they are damningly clarifying.

    Reply

  10. rondity
    December 11, 2017

    nice article

    Reply

  11. Barry Benedict
    January 17, 2018

    It just seems a lot simpler to me to call an illness which is caused by a pathogen (virus or germ) a disease and an illness which is caused by NO outside pathogen a sickness.
    I think there is a stigma connected to having mental illness which people are trying to avoid even though it simply muddies the waters.
    Those who deal professionally with this problem could just as easily CHANGE to the easier method without causing a problem and clearing up the confusion at the same time.

    Reply

    • Steph
      January 30, 2018

      Dear Barry,

      If you’re interested, Dr TS Szasz dedicated a chapter to exploring the reasons why people usually refer to “mental illness” rather than “mental disease”.

      It is a clarifying and subtly insightful exploration of what so-called mental illnesses and diagnoses are, and how they differ from physical diseases and diagnoses -all starting with a careful look at our use of language and the meanings, use, and connotations of ‘ill’ versus ‘sick’/’diseased’.

      I’m sorry, I don’t recall which book of his it was in. At usual, reading Szasz was a beautiful and thought-changing tour de force -well worth locating and reading.

      Reply

  12. Sriparna Dey
    December 3, 2018

    This information is very useful to me…& Help me…

    Thank you so much

    Reply

  13. Sue Hayden
    January 18, 2019

    Let’s not quibble over what is a disease or an illness. We are all God’s children so we need to show compassion to all.

    Reply

  14. Rufai Muhammad
    November 19, 2021

    If to now i don’t read any responsible meaning about deases and illness so gave us a genius reason and there different.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop