Difference Between Similar Terms and Objects

Difference Between Amish and Mennonite

amish_peopleAmish vs Mennonite

Amish or Amish Mennonite are a very traditional sect or a subgroup of the Mennonite Church. Founder of this sect was Jakob Amman and his followers came to be known Amish. Mennonites are a Christian group of Anabaptists following the teachings of their swiss founders. The name Mennonites is drawn from Frisian Menno Simons who through his works articulated the teachings of the original peaceful Anabaptists.

Anabaptists literally means ‘again Baptists’ believe that the meaningful baptism of an individual into the faith can only happen once the individual is old enough to take an informed decision about the future of his life. It is only then that an indivisual can truly commit to lead his life as per the lord’s teachings. Both Amish Mennonites and Mennonites are Anabaptists. Apart from this they are very different.

Where the Amish Mennonites have come to observe very strict and traditional practices the Mennonites have established a reputation of being very strict followers of non violence. Mennonites are also known as the peace church.

However, the main distinguishing feature of Amish from the Mennonites is the Amish resistance to embrace modern technology. Amish make very little use of technology and generally maintain very little contact with the outside world, no more than necessary. They dress up in very traditional outfits and live in very small tight knit communities. The Mennonites on the other hand dress up in plain clothes but generally would not be distinguishable from anyone else by their clothes. They neither have any problems using technology and nor maintain a separation from the outside world. The Mennonite Central Committee has established itself as a disaster relief organization around the world. Not only are the volunteers available immediately after a disaster but they also plan long term programs to run alongside and complement the international relief programs. They have programs running for HIV affected populations in Africa, Tsunami victims in India and Thailand, war affected areas in Afghanistan and the middle east. The Mennonites have been providing food, blankets, relief kits, drinking water, education by way of setting up schools, HIV awareness, etc.

Amish Mennonite communities generally hold services in private homes of the members. Besides their strong commitment to lead a simple life by minimum use of technology the Amish are also firm believers in Nonresistance. They seldom defend themselves in court for the same reason. Members not following the church rules are often excommunicated but given a chance to correct their behavior and return to the church. The Mennonites have their own churches but do not live in separate communities. They live amongst the normal population. Although practicing a plain and simple lifestyle they are much more moderate towards the use of modern technology and do not abstain from it.

1.Amish is a subgroup of Mennonites following Jakob Amman. Mennonites follow the teachings of peaceful Anabaptists popularized by Frisian Menno Simons.
2.Amish are very resistant to technology whereas Mennonites are moderate in this regard.
3.Amish are strict followers of nonresistance where the Mennonites are of non violence and have established a very strong disaster management system.
4.Amish have a very strong commitment to lead a simple lifestyle and live in separate close knit communities, however, the Mennonites live among the normal communities.

Search DifferenceBetween.net :

Custom Search

Help us improve. Rate this post! 1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (14 votes, average: 2.93 out of 5)

Email This Post Email This Post : If you like this article or our site. Please spread the word. Share it with your friends/family.


  1. I found this article to be inaccurate when it speaks of the way us Mennonites dress. We wear cape dresses very few groups wear skirt and blouse. The Amish however wear a cape dress of a different kind. As Mennonites our clothing is meant to stand out because the Bible tells us come ye out from among them. If possible please correct these errors. Other than that I find this article to he very good.

    • I was reading a book that mentioned Mennonites and Amish and became interested in them and the difference between the two. Danki to all who have added info on this topic.

  2. The Bible also tells you to kill your neighbor if you see them working on the Sabbath.. But I never see your kind do that … Pick and choose from the Bible much?

    • What was the point in that comment of yours Jezmund? That is poor taste and not necessary.

    • I don’t know what Bible you read from but does not kill your neighbors for ANY reason. The writings of Jesus does not state that. Your lost.

      • Exodus 31:15
        English Standard Version (ESV)

        • That is from the Old Testament… Christians believe that Jesus came down and in a sense “re-wrote” much of the old testament. This is the same mindset and reasoning for why Christians have no problem eating “unclean” animals, as they are listed in the Old Testament.

          • “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have come not to abolish them but to fulfil them. I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” Matthew 5:17-19

    • What is the point of nasty comments…do you pick on everyone that isn’t just like you.

    • this is very unaccurate

    • This is taken totally out of context. No one is directed to kill their neighbor if they work on the sabbath.

    • Where as we were under the law, with the birth of Christ we are now under grace, where it was an eye for an eye it’s now do good to those who abuse you, forgive those who trespass against you. Those without sin cast the first stone.

      • “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have come not to abolish them but to fulfil them. I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” Matthew 5:17-19

  3. I don’t know what Bible you read from but THE BIBLE does not state to kill your neighbors for ANY reason. The writings of Jesus does not state that. Your lost.

  4. There are many different kinds of Mennonites. Some wear all black, only drive a horse and buggy while others drive cars but strip the chrome from them.

    Then there are the modern Mennonites who dress as ordinary people, live in modern, sometimes beautiful homes and drive various kinds of cars and believe in education where the above do not go above grade 8.

    The in between Mennonite women often wear very colorful dresses, a little long, very plain and homemade. The men dress like other men. The women wear a little hat, especially when praying.

  5. as a child, i believe that mennonites are one of a kind. my aunt and uncle are menonite and my dad was adopted. so im sorta mennonite, i love my family. so i dont want to here any bad things about the mennonite culture. thank you and have a nice day.

    jessica lynn martin,
    age 17

  6. Found the article to be very interesting. Also, found the responses of great interest. Wish there had been more with regards to why some Mennonites use common place tools and others don’t. We just recently had a number of Mennonites move into our community and I am reluctant to go over and introduce myself and welcome them to our area. I know how I felt when I moved into the area and no one ever offered to even introduce themselves. Wondering what I should do? Any suggestions?

    • Reading the comments posted regarding this article. I saw your comment. I hope you gained the courage to welcome your neighbors to the community. You express your sympathy toward them based on your experiences of being the new kid on the block. It is sometimes hard to be the first person to step out and welcome in those who are different without fear of being frowned upon by others. You are not alone. I read about 12 others who went through something similar at times in their lives. 🙂

  7. I was born and raised in Philadelphia and have always had respect for the ways of life of others regardless of whether I agree or not. The number one respect I have is the Right to Freedom. So long as we do not force ourselves on the rights of others we deserve the right to choose our ways. Calling out names and making others believe that you are right isn’t the way of peace. Setting the example for others is respecting their rights provided that we all do the right thing. I believe humanity should believe in the ability to reason. This separates us from animals. And even in the animal world they, too, have wisdom that humans can learn from. I wish all of us could live with respect to each other, unite in the common cause to protect each other and our rights; but above all, to worship in our own way and respect life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness in our own way. I am sure that the Power of God will allow us to do so, and so should we. Peace to all as we can live in harmony. Former member of the 28th INF DIV PAARNG. Ben Franklin’s Associates 111th INF


  9. I have never been “afraid” to speak to an Amish or Mennonite individual. They have invited me into their home and offered refreshments. They also were very encouraging to ask any questions and give a very honest answer.
    The only time I would not approach an Amish or Mennonite individual was when I knew that it would be considered a break in proper manners as they understood. I try to respect any culture, religion, or nationality, until I have reason to be suspect.
    To these two groups of Americans, please do not let rude, ignorant comments deter you.

  10. I forgot to add “A Blessed Christmas to you all.”

  11. William Penn travelled to Europe offering land to those that would come to Pennsylvaia and help settle it. Mennonites took advantage of this offer. The Amish broke away from the Mennonites in 1893 because they felt the Mennonites were becoming too liberal in their ways. The Amish worshipped in private houses, with each family taking their turn. Recently (1970s), the Amish split between the House Amish and the Church Amish. The Church Amish has plain meeting houses. The House Amish still follow the idea of meeting in homes. Clothing can be quite colorful but seem not to be with the pinafore type dark aprons worn over the dress. I have always been interested. Plain living and depending and caring for each other and on themselves.

  12. What do the Amish or Mennonite believe in the spirit and the Spirit?? 1Cor6;17

    Is the spirit the same as the soul? if not why need to divide the soul from the spirit? Heb 4;12

    The 3 parts of man!! 1Thes5;23

    How does one worship God? Jn 4;24 How??

    Why was Cain’s offering not accept by God? The beginning of Religion!!
    Man’s Religion? Man does what he wants to offering to God?

    Is Adam a pre-figure to Christ? Adam was put to sleep (death) and Eve was built from something that came out of Adam!
    OUT of Christ SIDE (body) on the Cross the Church is being built

  13. Wow! I didn’t expect such an interesting list of replies. I believe that the Bible is designed to reflect what is in a person’s heart. One of the attributes of the gift of the Holy Spirit is Love. Yeshua refers to Love as the greatest commandment. The intention of Judeo/Christianity is to teach of spiritual things. Without the discernment that comes from being baptized in the Holy Spirit, the things of the Bible can seem contradictory. Yeshua came so that the fullness of the message could be completed. Without the Old Testament, the New does not have full meaning. That is what Yeshua means by “not one portion of the law”. It’s complete when baptism gives us His Holy Spirit & we can see more of the whole picture of the law. “Clothes do not necessarily make the man” maybe in this case we are using clothing to define various sects or groups of people. When I was a child, Amish women were separate from Mennonite from hair styles. Amish women did not have an wisps of hair and nothing was to touch the back of the neck. Supposedly it was based on bible verses. Who knows? Star bellied Sneeches maybe? Man’s efforts to be holy? Tks for posting all of the comments! Thought & prayer provoking!

  14. Through hairstyles! Not from, but, that is grammatical.

  15. Interesting comments!!!!! I am a Mennonite and very happy with my religion. In regards to the question on homosexuality we definitely would believe it is wrong. (See the first chapter of Romans) Of utmost importance is to find forgiveness with Jesus. I was far out in sin in drugs and many awful things and Jesus has given me a totally new life and power to stay away from it all. Even cigarettes. That is what is so awesome to me is it is REAL. It’s not what a preacher or bishop or any other leader wants you to believe. Peace with God is a personal relationship with Christ Jesus. It is possible to all and I promise when you find it you will know without any doubt it is real. God bless you all

Leave a Response

Please note: comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Articles on DifferenceBetween.net are general information, and are not intended to substitute for professional advice. The information is "AS IS", "WITH ALL FAULTS". User assumes all risk of use, damage, or injury. You agree that we have no liability for any damages.

See more about :
Protected by Copyscape Plagiarism Finder