5 responses

  1. bruce hyman
    December 3, 2012

    You’ve moved Islam back 1300 years before it began. Whatever you think of Islam, 600 BC doesn’t cut it.

    Then, on a more substantive note, there’s this: “both cultures are forcing the other to heed the call to accept their religions.” Well, the article was not written by a person whose native language is English, which is ok. What is not ok is when the mistranslation destroys meaning. What do you mean when you say that the US is forcing (say) Saudi Arabia to “accept” Christianity?

    And, do you believe that (say) Saudi Arabia wants the US to “accept” Islam? Well, last time I looked, the US accepts Muslim-Americans, so I can’t think it’s a big stretch for the US to accept Muslim Saudis.

    Or this: “English literature has a long history and has been seen as the foundational platform of the existing world literature.” thanks, but let’s get real. there is a HUGE world literature that was not written in English, nor even translated into English; to say that English (is) the “foundational platform for the existing world literature” is at best an exaggeration.
    Then there’s this: “Countries that are predominantly Muslim speak and write Arabic.” Accoring to the CIA world factbook, Indonesian languages include “Bahasa (the official, modified form of Malay), English, Dutch, and local dialects (of which the most widely spoken is Javanese). Arabic doesn’t make the list.
    Or this: “American interference in Arab affairs within Arab lands (the Jewish issue) has been hailed as terrorism by the Arab nations.” First, you conflate Islam and Arab, which are independent, if overlapping, concepts: There are Christian Arabs and there are non-Arab Muslims. That said, whatever the “Jewish issue” is (and as a Jew I haven’t a clue what you mean here), no form of American interference in Arab affairs within Arab lands has anything to do with Judaism. you continue: “The American side see it [sic] as a socio-economic pursuit to establish a presence in the Arab region.” Whatever “it” is, the sentence cannot be read with the word “terrorism” in place of the word “it”, unless you think that terrorism is in any sense a “socio-economic pursuit”

    Reply

  2. liz
    April 26, 2013

    Islam began after 600 AD… who let you write this article to fool everyone?
    Christianity was well established before mohammad was born.

    Reply

  3. yahya maadidi
    November 18, 2013

    I agree with Mr. Bruce Hyman for all things he said.

    You are who wrote the article involved yourself in a knowledge that has nothing to know about!!!

    You Made from American an Ethnic group and race. They are not!

    Being Arab means Semitic, Arabic speaker and has Arabian culture.
    Being American is being someone else ( European, Latino, negro, Chinese, Arab,…….etc) but living in what is politically called USA and have a paper that says that he is citizen of USA.
    If you say that Americans are English speakers, then I tell you that my grandmother who can say 10 words in English only is also American because she has the PASSPORT.

    Arabs as ethnic founded 500 BC. Americans are founded 200 years ago if not mistaken.
    Besides all, Arabs are the longest survived ethnic group in the entire world. No other group kept itself as same group for 2500 years than Arabs. (Romans kept themselves for 1 400 years).

    Arabs can be Muslims, Christians, Jews and sabians only. No other than these.

    Arab is an Arab in his treatory or outside it. American need to show his ID to be recognized as American inside America. And most times the America is called with different identity in America itself like Black-american, Arab-american, Latino-american and even Arab-american.
    American can NOT be an Arab. But Arab can be an American.

    From today and perhaps till year 2500, if USA keep itself united and isolate itself from other parts of the world, that time an ethnic called American will be established. independant ethnic and culture.

    If the economical situation become very bad in America. Half population of America will return back to their home countries. That time, they will never call themselves Americans, but they will return to their ethnical backgrounds. This has happened with Chinese Americans when china got better living condition.

    With my respect to all Americans including the black Americans 😉

    Reply

  4. Nabhan
    October 27, 2018

    LOL Free spirit? Do not make me laugh! That his democracy is in black water!

    Reply

  5. Desertmann
    July 4, 2021

    There are clear bias toward one group in this article.
    And so many mistakes and generalization, He even goes to say that Arabic Language originated from Hebrew and Aramaic? what kind of info you brought here! The 3 languages are sister language born from a common Semitic branch. For example the word God in:
    Aramaic is Allaha
    Arabic is Allah
    Hebrew Eloh (Elohim is plural of respect)
    they sound similar because the share common origin

    there are so many things wrong in the article.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop