6 responses

  1. Muttaquee HUSAIN
    October 14, 2012

    I would have appreciated if in this article Urdu was given its place as it deserves.

    Reply

  2. snehashish khankal
    December 1, 2012

    I agree with Husain. Hindi is spoken in India and the language spoken in Pakistan in “Urdu” not Hindustani. Hindi and Urdu are derived from Hindustani which is further derived from Khariboli dialect from Delhi. Urdu extensively uses Persian and Arabic words whereas Hindi is a Sanskritized version of Hindustani.

    Reply

  3. ram
    October 28, 2013

    Yeah – the above guys are right. Hindustani is the mother language of Hindi and Urdu, both of which are derviatives of Hindustani. Hindi is spoken primarily in India, where as Urdu in Pakistan (and amongst many of the South Asian Muslim community).

    Reply

  4. Nadir
    April 17, 2015

    This article aims to substitute Urdu with Hindustani and distinguishes Hindi from Hindustani. This is incorrect. Hindustani is BOTH Hindi and Urdu.

    Hindi and Urdu are the two distinct forms of Hindustani. Nothing complicated. Hindustani is not necessarily Hindi since both Hindi and Urdu are Hindustani. But Hindi is always Hindustani since both Hindi and Urdu are Hindustani.

    Reply

  5. jisg
    May 20, 2017

    Incorrect. Hindi IS the sanskritic original. It was bastardised under Mughal occupation to create a lingua franca called Hindustani. Persian Arabic words were inducted as the grammar is advanced and flexible. When written in Arabic script it, Hindustani cane to b known as Urdu. Grammatically, urdu is Hindi.

    Reply

  6. Atif
    September 17, 2018

    I am not sure how many people have to comment here before this article is revised.

    Hindi is a subset of Hindustani, just like Urdu. Hindustani is not really spoken in its original form anywhere. People in India speak mostly Hindi (and some Urdu) while all of Pakistan speaks Urdu (and not Hindustani).

    It seems if you replace the word “Hindustani” with “Urdu” in this article, everything else will fall into place.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop