2 responses

  1. Gator
    October 6, 2011

    This rating is so imprecise as to be useless. IF he’s only referring to the lower line Dot and Sheraton, he may be right.

    But the Elite (and Elitist) series Sheratons are hands-down far superior to the Dot. And the Sheraton 11 Reissue (made for only a few years in the mid-2000s) is arguably one of the very best thin hollow body guitars ever made by anyone. Both series had USA Gibson pick-ups and hardware on a body made at the extremely capable Japanese factory and were assembled in the US.

    In fact, most pros I know consider the latter (USA reissue) to be better than the Gibbe 335, and I agree with that. The reason Gibson stopped making them (after only 50 were put out) is that all of the professional reviews said, “Don’t spend $3500 on a Gibbe, spend $1300 and you’ll actually have a better guitar.” The reviews were all 10+ on a scale of 10. I’ve never seen any guitar that was so widely praised by the guitar press in my 40+ years of playing.

    My main guitar is a true 1968 LP Custom Black Beauty and my favorite acoustics are my Gibbe acoustics from the first half of the 20th century, so I’m not putting down Gibson– I love them. It’s just that when you say “Sheraton” without qualifying which model, you’re talking about a range of guitars that goes from the very mediocre to one of the finest hollow-body electrics ever made.

    Reply

  2. Duane Harris
    October 30, 2019

    You goofed the dot has a set in mahogany neck

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop