Difference Between Dumb And Mute

What is the difference between ‘dumb’ and ‘mute’? The words are synonyms for each other. They both refer to being speechless, and the expression ‘deaf and dumb’ is known by English speakers.  However, although the meaning by definition may be the same of these words, the usage can be very different, especially when referring to people. It should be noted that using ‘dumb’ is often inappropriate, and possibly even using ‘mute’ sometimes.

Dumb is an adjective. Its original meaning is to be lacking the power of speech. ‘Dumb’ can be used to describe animals and inanimate objects that obviously have no ability to talk. This meaning is expressed in ‘dumb waiter’, which is a mechanical device to carry things, like food and dishes between floors of a house or building. It is called ‘dumb’ because it acts like a human waiter delivering food or other items, but of course cannot talk because it is an inanimate object.

‘Dumb’ has another usage with humans. It means incapable of using speech because of being mute and unable to speak, most typically because of congenital deafness, or the inability to hear. However, it is not used in this way in modern speech by most people, and it can actually be considered quite offensive. The only way it is generally used in English today is to mean temporarily speechless, as with shock or fear. For example: I was dumb with disbelief when she appeared out of nowhere. Less frequently, but sometimes still used, it can also mean to be unwilling to speak, as in being shy. For example: Don’t just stand there dumb, say something!

The reason ‘dumb’ is often unacceptable to use in English relates to its other and more modern meaning of being conspicuously unintelligent or stupid. In this way, ‘dumb’ as slang is most often used by English speakers. For example: That was a dumb mistake. It can also be used to indicate that something was unintentional or haphazard, and that it did not require any skill. This is evident in the expression ‘dumb luck’. Because of this usage, it is considered offensive to refer to a person that cannot speak as ‘dumb’. It implies that the lack of ability to speak comes from a lack of intelligence or development, which is not the case in a deaf person.

‘Mute’ has the meaning of being unable to speak, similarly to ‘dumb’. Historically, ‘deaf-mute’ was a term to identify a person that was deaf and could not speak. While it still continues to be used to refer to people that are unable to speak, it can be considered offensive by some. It should be used with caution when referring to people. Most deaf people prefer to simply be considered ‘deaf’, even though that term does not have any bearing on a person’s ability to speak. ‘Mute’, however, is still often used to refer to inanimate objects. It most commonly, perhaps, used as verb meaning to turn off the sound of something. For example: Please mute the T.V., I am on the phone.

Sharing is caring!