1 response

  1. Joe Bradfield
    May 21, 2020

    As an old scoutmaster, I respectfully disagree. You need another category, first of all. You need to compare a “hand ax” to a “hatchet.” Comparing 3/4 and full axes to a hatchet is comparing tools from different size classes. “Hand ax” should be compared to “hatchet,” and distinguished by their differing features. In the absence of one, the other can be substituted but is generally the wrong tool.

    I think over the decades, with a variety of new designs introduced from numerous regions of the world, the terms have become confused.

    A hand ax, like larger axes, has a “bellied” handle for greater control — unlike hatchets, which typically have straight handles. A wooden hand ax handle has a broad shoulder and “poll” at one end and its knob at the other, both wider than the rest of the handle (though cheap axes that integrate metal handle with metal head most often do not have a broadened shoulder).

    The hand ax head is typically broader than an ax, which tapers much more from bit to handle.

    There are a variety of hatchets. The most familiar is the one used by roofers for use splitting. Roofing hatchets often have a hammer head opposite the blade. The hammer head can be used to drive small nails.

    Hand axes should never be used to drive anything metal, and really shouldn’t be used to drive wooden tent stakes (though it’s so tempting to do). That’s because a hand ax head is often softer metal than a hammer. Using a hand ax to hammer metal stakes or nails not only mars the ax head but can send red-hot pieces of metal flying. One of our assistant scoutmasters has a bit of ax head metal that did just that beneath the skin on his neck.

    Hand axes and hatchets are two different tools, whose designs were meant for different applications.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop