10 responses

  1. Mati
    July 7, 2017

    “technicians use computers to diagnose problems”

    It isn’t true. Today, computers are used to many, many things, like E-mails, researching or reading of technicial documentation.

    I think, working as a technician has very little to do with computer. If You are computer or network technician – OK. If You not – it is only addition to Your work.

    Reply

    • Sam
      February 28, 2020

      This is a new age. I’m a technician/mechanic for BMW. A computer system plays a huge role in finding the solution to a problem and I use one every day for that specific reason

      Reply

  2. Mati
    July 7, 2017

    Second thing.

    Your art is a depreciation of mechanic profession. It is not about names – it is about job professionalism.

    Reply

  3. Page
    August 18, 2017

    I’m a certified master Ford technician and I can assure you this explanation, while properly defining the words “technician” and “mechanic”, is totally wrong.
    In this day and age, it would be far too inefficient to have a shop with “technicians” diagnosing a problem, sending it to the “mechanic” to fix it, then back to the “technician” to make sure it’s properly fixed.
    No, it doesn’t work like that.
    If someone wants to fix automobiles for a living nowadays, they will have to be able to do everything a “technician” and “mechanic” does.
    This is why we don’t make enough money.

    Reply

    • Bill king
      September 15, 2017

      Here Ye here Ye !!! If you know what that means you are both !!!!

      Reply

  4. kgoji
    December 31, 2017

    I think the definition are in general correct, ‘in general’s, and actually technician and machenic supposed to do as the definition says above, the problems is that companies Norway’s are pushing for profit and they want their staff to be lean, so they won’t be able or afford to have both the two, now organisation as big a NASA or Boeing yes will go that route. So guys don’t feel offended cos there is nothing offensive here

    Reply

  5. Rollie Hunt
    July 11, 2018

    Mechanics have had complex diagnostics tools for decades before the relatively recent trend of calling them technicians. These same mechanics also made the repairs. To me this trend is driven by companies who want to attract new young employees by giving those normally less desireble positions the more attractive job title of technician.

    Reply

  6. Donald Smithson
    March 27, 2019

    You are so out of date even back in 2016
    mechanics have been using oscilloscopes /computers for years for diagnosis as they are only some of the diagnosis tools used by mechanics
    So when a mechanic diagnoses a fault using equipment is he then a technician or a qualified mechanic ?
    Dictionaries are only written by a person with limited experience and using there imagination as to what/ think they know what a tradesman does,
    they think some one with a blue collar cannot use there brain.

    But can you give an academic a tool and then know the technical knowledge how to make it operate and function properly not just give a technical information only

    Reply

  7. Doug
    November 9, 2019

    I’ve been a mobile heavy equipment mechanic for 30 years, always working at dealerships. I am proficient and very comfortable with computer diagnostics. But a computer is nothing more than a fancy multimeter. A real diagnostic person uses all of his senses including codes and computer parameters. The guys that rely on their computers are the ones I have to constantly go behind.

    Reply

  8. Jason
    August 2, 2021

    In Canada journeymen/red seal mechanics get a certificate as as automotive service technicians so this is not correct. Also if you take your car to a mechanic who can not diagnose the issue and has to rely on a technician to diagnose it take it somewhere else. A mechanic should be able to diagnose and repair a vehicle!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop