Introduction
Both the Ottoman and Roman Empires were stretched over large swathes of the earth. While the Ottoman Empire, which was established by Osman 1, was a world power from 1299AD and 1923AD, the Roman Empire, whose first emperor was Augustus, dominated the world from 27BC to 476AD. The Ottoman Empire’s capital was Istanbul, while the Roman Empire’s capital was Rome. In the Ottoman Empire, only the son of the Sultan could succeed him as ruler. The Roman Empire, on the other hand, was a republic with a senate that voted on who would be appointed as Caesar (Potter, 1999).
Differences Between the Ottoman and Roman Empires
The Ottoman Empire lasted longer than the Roman Empire, which only existed for five and a half centuries. The differences between the two empires also extend to their religious, scientific, cultural and political structures. Soldiers of the Ottoman Empire had more advanced weapons than those of the Roman soldiers, as firearms were non-existent 2000 years ago.
Sultans like Mehmed II took personal interest in scientific discussions and the establishment of educational institutions in the kingdom. Some of the most significant scholars in mathematics and astronomy, like Taki al- Din al-Rasid, championed the sciences within schools in the Ottoman Empire. Mehmed II personally oversaw the establishment of the Kayışdağı, Kırkçeşme, Hamidiye, Cev’mi-i Şerife and Taksim water systems (Masters, 2001). He also funded the construction of 33 Sukemeri (aqueducts) like the Mağlova Kemeri, Kovuk Kemer, Güzelce Kemer, Uzunkemer, and Paşa Kemeri (Masters, 2001). Roman engineers mainly focused on creating vaults, arches, and aqueduct systems that would serve the needs of their many cities.
Women in the Ottoman as well as the Roman Empire were expected to live under the protection of men. In the Roman Empire, the lives of all women were dictated by their husbands, sons, or fathers. Only vestal virgins, who served the gods and goddesses in numerous temples, were somewhat free to live their lives as they saw fit. Even though women in the Ottoman Empire had limited lives outside the home, there were many regular events that allowed them to leave their homes.
For instance, in celebrations such as paca günü and kina gecesi, women would celebrate engagement and wedding preparations outside their homes (Keating, 2007). There was even a period between the 16th and 17th centuries when women like Ayşe Hafsa Sultan , Mihrimah Sultan, Hürrem Sultan, and Kösem Sultan ruled the Empire because the emperors were either incompetent, or in their minority (Keating, 2007). The famous Sultana Valideh, Hürrem, actually received foreign officials and advised the emperor on different subjects simply because he respected her intellect.
The Ottoman Empire had just one state religion- Islam. Even though non-Muslim subjects were encouraged to convert to Islam, Christians and Jews were allowed to practice their religions in accordance with the Treaty of Umar ibn al-Khattab (Masters, 2001). In contrast, the Roman Empire supported the worship of a collection of deities known as the Pantheon (Potter, 1999). The pantheon included gods like Mars, Apollo, Pluto, Neptune, Jupiter, Janus and Bacchus; as well as goddesses like Juno, Venus, Minerva, and Proserpine (Mehta-Jones, 2004).
Slaves were a part of both the Roman and Ottoman Empires. In Roman society, slaves had no rights. They could be mistreated, misused, and even murdered by their masters with no penalty being exacted by the justice system. In the Ottoman Empire, Muslims could not be held as slaves unless they were prisoners of war. There were also Islamic laws that guaranteed slaves the right to medical care, shelter, food, and clothing. Slaves also had the right to marry who they wished to. The Sultans believed that killing un-ransomed captives of war was un-Islamic, and a waste of military capital. This is why they authorized the drafting of young Christian male captives in the Yeniceri (janissary) elite regiment (Masters, 2001).
Conclusion
The Roman and Ottoman empires existed in different millennia, and each of their boundaries stretched into Asia, Africa, and Europe. Even though both empires were ruled by authoritarian rulers, their political, religious, and cultural structures had significant differences.
- The Differences between Socialism and National Socialism - April 8, 2016
- The Differences Between The Pharisees and Sadducees - April 8, 2016
- The Difference Between The Hindu Calendar and The Gregorian Calendar - April 8, 2016
Roman Empire lasted 1500 yrs – in fact it was the Ottoman Empire that finally ended the Roman Empire.
The entity we now call the ‘Byzantine Empire’ was/is the Roman Empire. Historians only started calling it ‘Byzantine Empire’ in 1800’s. For all its existence. It was called the Roman Empire. period.
Reply
That part of the empire was always considered different to ge Latin or western empire anyway because they were mainly influenced by the Greeks. The eastern Roman Empire out of Constantinople was where all the glory and from anyway so it’s probably best to disregard the empire in the Italian peninsula
Reply
Both cultures’ descendants are nowadays considered the scum of Europe.
Reply
This article would be very interesting had its info on the Roman Empire been accurate. The Roman Empire did not end in 476, at all. The Western provinces began to fragment and eventually fell, but the Eastern Roman Empire, with its capital in Constantinople, would continue to exist for another 1000 years, until it finally fell to the Ottomans in 1453. And don’t even attempt to tell me it was the “Byzantine Empire”, there was never an Empire called “Byzantine”. It is a term made up long after the end of the Empire by butthurt Western Europeans, who wanted to pretend that The Empires legacy belonged to the west. So they invented the intentionally misleading term “Byzantine” in a disrespectful attempt to separate the long lived Eastern Roman Empire from its own history and identity, and pretend like the entire empire ended with the West in 476. An obnoxiously incorrect notion that intentionally overlooks one of the Empires greatest achievements, that it continued until 1453, which is pretty bloody amazing. Hell, the capital had already been transferred to Constantinople in 330, well over a century before the West was even lost. It also managed to remain the most powerful political entity in Europe despite being cut in half, up until the very last 200 years of its existence. (Thanks crusaders, could’ve held out longer had it not been for the fourth crusade sacking Constantinople) Also its citizens, government, and neighbors all continued to refer to the old beast simply as the Roman Empire, because that’s exactly what it was. Pretenders like Charlemagne were playing emperor in Western Europe while the real, original Roman Empire was still surviving in the East. Really this needs a major rewrite or just shitcanned altogether. Roman Empire 27 BC-AD 1453
Reply